All you abusers post your Nikon Drop test experience here. « Nikon Rumors Forum

The new Nikon Rumors Forum is now live at http://forum.nikonrumors.com/discussions. This forum is now in "read only" mode until I figure a proper way to import all data over to the new platform. Please register over at the new forum.


Nikon Rumors Forum

where there’s smoke there’s forum fire

Register or log in - lost password?

Nikon Rumors Forum » Nikon DSLR

All you abusers post your Nikon Drop test experience here.

(108 posts) (64 voices)
  • Started 2 years ago by Nikoner
  • Latest reply from dazey
  • Related Topics:
    1. D90 Price Dropping came to its end ?
    2. PHOTO-A-DAY: October 2012
    3. Insane deals and lucky finds
    4. Learn from my expensive mistake
    5. Nikon D7000 vs D300

Tags:

  • 24-70
  • 24mm 1.4g
  • 80-200 AFS
  • Abuse
  • Bears
  • D200
  • D7000
  • D90
  • D90,D7000,Nikon,D800
  • drop
  • dropped
  • F100
  • fell
  • gallery
  • louboutin shoes
  • lowepro
  • oops
  • safety
  • www
« Previous12345Next »
  1. rbid

    preferred member
    Joined: Jan '11
    Posts: 344

    offline

    ChrisLange said:
    My cameras get treated well, most of the time, but there's no telling what might happen when I'm out.

    My Rolleiflex has smacked off the corners of tables and walls when making quick turns with it off my shoulder, it's fine.

    My Nikkormat FT2 has fallen onto concrete numberous times, aside from a tiny crack in the mirror, which is invisible in the viewfinder, it works perfectly.

    My Pentax 6x7 has fallen and slammed into a lot of stuff. I think it causes more damage than it receives.

    My F4 has been used as a weapon as part of a dodgy situation I had in Vyborg, Russia. I was being followed down a back alley by a suspicious looking fellow, who was yelling at me in Russian, apparently paying no mind to my shouts of "NYET" and "ÄLÄ NYT". I had my 85/1.4 Ai-S on the camera, with the large metal screw-in hood. So when I was faced with no exit, and him looking like he was about to take a knife or something out of his pocket, I took the camera by the vertical grip and slammed the hood into the guy's nose. He doubled-over and I took off running back to the central square. The 85 is no worse for wear, and the F4 is still in consant use. The hood has a unnoticeable flat spot on the base, which I think is more from the camera being set down on the ground, than anything else.

    My Hasselblad has been smacked around a bit, but it shoots like new. It's a 500C from 1962, which I had overhauled in December of 2010.

    The only camera I've ever had break on me was my Yashica Electro35 GS, which sufferes from an internal electronics issue common to that model of camera.

    My first camera was a "Ricoh Singlex TLS" (that I got for my 13Bday in 1973), with a 55mm lens. During the early 80' I felt down from a waterfall deep into a pool here in Israel, with the camera hanging on my neck.. That same day, I returned home, got some alcohol and small screw-drivers and opened the camera completely, I have dried and cleaned the camera, knowing that I have nothing to loose. After putting the camera back, all worked as required, even the exposure meter was working!.. just got a small hit on the filter thread and that was all. I always remember that day with all the table full of screws.. I guess that no camera in these days would survive a dive like that one, that required me to swim to reach a place I can stand and put the camera out of danger.

    Posted 2 years ago #
  2. ChrisLange

    preferred member
    Joined: Apr '09
    Posts: 359

    offline

    There is absolutely a difference in build quality these days. I recently was given an F3/T by my glassblowing professor at university, and in comparison to my already rock-solid normal F3, the titanium one has literally no flex anywhere on the body at all.

    Posted 2 years ago #
  3. kanuck

    preferred member
    Joined: Apr '09
    Posts: 1,405

    offline

    Only times I have damaged any Nikon gear was back in 2006, my D40 with shitty 18-105mm lens on a manfroto tripod. Very windy day legs weren't out enough on tripod end of the day tired I guess and she all blew right over on me. Body got scratched up pretty good, but lens broke off and only 10% was hanging on the mount still! haha it was unreal I could hold it up with one hand and could actually continue shooting but only manually.

    Other accident was a dropped 50mm 1.4 D and it was worse, with a cracked element but fixed it for $125 and then sold it 2 months later. I am extra careful now I find. Haven't dropped anything since 2007, touch wood.

    Nice discussion thread :)

    Posted 2 years ago #
  4. Mike Gunter

    preferred member
    Joined: Sep '10
    Posts: 946

    offline

    Hi,

    I've mentioned some rough stuff in Vietnam. We had to wade ditches with my cameras over my head and sometimes I and everything with me sank and I had to dry it off the best way possible. Generally, it worked out, but often not so good. It was hit and miss. Our cameras did fail over time. The humidity got to them and we replaced them.

    One thing an F won't stop is a bullet. That's not a drop test, but it does a job on it. I was wearing it at the time and didn't notice it until sometime after it happened during the firefight - that 'fog of war' thing. I wasn't hit, nor was anyone else, we think, from that bullet, and the roll in the camera was toast.

    My abuse of equipment is pretty bad. I've sent many cameras and lenses to heaven or hell (depending on whether they were bad or good, of course). In news sometimes an angry subject would just rip a camera from my hands and throw it on the ground. If he were a penniless criminal (and one was) the paper's insurance would have to pay (and that was 'current value' - I think that lingo for 'as little as possible'). In the Army, some of the equipment would get run over by tanks (odd as that sounds, it happens) or during a training flight, it can fall out of a door (that hasn't happened to me, but my guys swore at attention to me that it did to them - I still wonder about that one) ;-).

    Sometimes it was my own fault. I'm getting more clumsy and awkward now than ever. I'm not too far from simply not affixing the camera to the tripod properly and letting the whole shebang fall - I don't have any hubris - it's happened to others, it can happen to me. It's likely just waiting for a good time.

    My best to all,

    Mike

    Posted 2 years ago #
  5. kanuck

    preferred member
    Joined: Apr '09
    Posts: 1,405

    offline

    Interesting stuff Mike. I agree the climate and landscape of Vietnam is very challenging to say the least. That is quite the story about the fire fight you endured. What were the soldiers like with regards to you snapping shots of them? Have you ever converted any of your war coverage into the digital media? I've had many a roll of film ripped out of my camera back in the day especially in pre Olympic Beijing. I have to take extra good care of my gear now because my employer has really crappy insurance at least I think anyways..

    Posted 2 years ago #
  6. Mike Gunter

    preferred member
    Joined: Sep '10
    Posts: 946

    offline

    Hi Kanuck,

    None of the pictures are mine. They belong to the Armed Services. I see picture every now and then, and I understand that there was a move prior to 9/11 to digitize all photos in the archives (I left civil service in 1995 when that was in the stages of being finalize). There are proponents of each specialty (not necessarily Army/Navy/Air Force, but Infantry, Air Defense, Chemical, Amphibian, etc.) that are shepherding a lot of the photos by content.

    They were like anyone. They were put in a bad place against their will and trying to make the best of it.

    Keep in mind, most photography was historical - change of command ceremonies, awards and decorations, what the units did on a certain day at a certain place. (On a side note, the one thing I _could have done, I regret not doing, was just taking more pictures of guys being guys - if I could rewind that clock, I would take 3 times as much film, and use 2/3ds of it doing that). People see guys wading rice fields with their rifles, but don't see them in their pole screen tent trying to wire their portable TV to the generator watch Star Trek or Laugh In or stinging up a white sheet to watch "Easy Rider" along side a ditch bank using a projector. Those are the images I missed getting that told a different story.

    My best,

    Mike

    Posted 2 years ago #
  7. bjrichus

    preferred member
    Joined: Nov '10
    Posts: 921

    offline

    Mike Gunter said:
    One thing an F won't stop is a bullet.

    Mike,

    I'm not being disrespectful or anything, but what is your view of Don McCullin and his (in)famous F that stopped a bullet from an AK in Vietnam?

    Posted 2 years ago #
  8. Mike Gunter

    preferred member
    Joined: Sep '10
    Posts: 946

    offline

    Hi bjrichus,

    Two different things. I was referring to 'stopping' and continuing.

    In my F's case, it plain stopped.

    My best,

    Mike

    Posted 2 years ago #
  9. Super Shooter

    preferred member
    Joined: Jun '10
    Posts: 277

    offline

    bjrichus said:
    Mike,

    I'm not being disrespectful or anything, but what is your view of Don McCullin and his (in)famous F that stopped a bullet from an AK in Vietnam?

    +1, how could you not think of that story?

    Mike Gunter said:
    I was referring to 'stopping' and continuing.

    In my F's case, it plain stopped.

    I don't understand what you mean by "stopping and continuing"? Unless your real name is Don McCullin.

    Posted 2 years ago #
  10. bjrichus

    preferred member
    Joined: Nov '10
    Posts: 921

    offline

    Mike Gunter said:
    Hi bjrichus,

    Two different things. I was referring to 'stopping' and continuing.

    In my F's case, it plain stopped.

    My best,

    Mike

    Just looked at a picture of it on Flickr and it looks like the bullet hit it to the left of the lens mount (at about 1pm as you look AT the camera form the front), just where the pentaprism and body come together.

    Sure does look like it was deflected off (I assume this is what you mean by continuing?), however, as I wasn't there at the time... I have had some nasty knocks and collisions with F series gear and even though that stuff always seems to be built like a tank (a coolpix would simply fall apart in my hands just thinking about some of that sort of use) I agree a camera might never "stop" a bullet ...

    Posted 2 years ago #
  11. rbid

    preferred member
    Joined: Jan '11
    Posts: 344

    offline

    This thread remembers me this video That I saw it in the past:

    [+] Embed the video | Video DownloadGet the Video Widget
    Text-Link:
    HTML-Link:
    BB-Code:
    Embed:
    (Not D90 but D70!

    [+] Embed the video | Video DownloadGet the Video Widget
    Text-Link:
    HTML-Link:
    BB-Code:
    Embed:

    Posted 2 years ago #
  12. Mike Gunter

    preferred member
    Joined: Sep '10
    Posts: 946

    offline

    Hi rbid,

    A lot of folks think that the guy is cheesy, but I get a real kick out a lot of his stuff. These videos were great (IMHO) and thanks for sharing. As goofy (and funny) as they were, there were some applicability to the world things - maybe not the camera as shoes - in them.

    @bjrichus and Super Shooter, bullets do strange things when they hit objects. Anyone in war who survives has a great bit of luck on his or her side. What happens isn't completely predictable. What I meant from the 'drop test' (what I gathered from the thread) is that the camera would continue to work or not when dropped or at what level of abuse they can take and continue to function.

    I would hate to have any camera drop from a tripod or have it spill into Earl Grey tea (video reference, if you haven't seen it), much less get hit by a 7.62mm round. Of the three, I doubt it would continue working after the round by a long shot. I wouldn't read much more into than that.

    My camera was hit from the side, the lens cracked from the impact, too. Many guys had 'things' that got hit during their time there. Packs, canteens, boot heels, trousers, helmets (that's the spooky thing), and some of us were not so lucky in that we didn't return unscathed.

    My best,

    Mike

    Posted 2 years ago #
  13. bjrichus

    preferred member
    Joined: Nov '10
    Posts: 921

    offline

    Mike Gunter said:
    Anyone in war who survives has a great bit of luck on his or her side. What happens isn't completely predictable.

    [...]

    My camera was hit from the side, the lens cracked from the impact, too. Many guys had 'things' that got hit during their time there. Packs, canteens, boot heels, trousers, helmets (that's the spooky thing), and some of us were not so lucky in that we didn't return unscathed.

    My father had a backpack radio strapped on for several months during WWII and it took several hits.

    He certainly attested to how bizarre (lucky?) you have to be to survive...

    Posted 2 years ago #
  14. bjrichus

    preferred member
    Joined: Nov '10
    Posts: 921

    offline

    rbid said:
    This thread remembers me this video That I saw it in the past:

    So there you have it... The butter knife and salad test prove that an SLR is up to the job.

    Only thing is that using a Nikon as a hammer (and seeing the lens scratched like that) is sad indeed.

    Posted 2 years ago #
  15. patrickdowns

    member
    Joined: Apr '11
    Posts: 24

    offline

    20+ years as a newspaper photog... I have dropped lots of gear. The best: I was pulling my fully-loaded 25# Domke bag out of the trunk, giving it a big yank to heave it up and onto my shoulder. The strap from an F2+lens, which was lying loose, caught and got launched. It was like the slo-mo scene from a movie...the camera spinning in the air, turning, turning about 6' up, flying away. I could hear myself, "Sh..............t!" It came down on the bottom corner of the body, and smashed a v-shaped dent in it. I took it to the shop and they checked everything out...no problem! Worked like new. I've loved Nikon's durability ever since, but I wouldn't want to do that with my D7000 :)

    Posted 2 years ago #
  16. kyoshinikon

    preferred member
    Joined: Jan '10
    Posts: 1,200

    offline

    While not a drop test here is a typical day for my D90...

    Posted 2 years ago #
  17. NikoDoby

    The Terminator
    Joined: May '09
    Posts: 6,598

    offline

    And then you'll start a thread asking us why your D90 sensor has spots all over it and whether you should return it because it might be defective. :^)

    *makes mental note never to buy a used camera from Kyoshi*

    Posted 2 years ago #
  18. nikkorz

    new member
    Joined: May '11
    Posts: 1

    offline

    I was sprawled out on the side of the road to get a low angle of my subjects. I had placed a 60mm G micro on the road next to me while shooting with a different lens. After warning my PA that it was there and to watch out for it, she went ahead and kicked it anyway. I watched it roll towards the curb right into very green, very smelly fluid that was leaking out of a nearby dumpster. after cleaning it, the smell persisted - the most putrid of smells, although the lens was undamaged. I eventually got the smell out but had to sell it, knowing where its been.

    back in my d50 days, my cat was young and reckless. I heard a thump in my office and found that he had knocked the d50 with a sb-800 and 18-70 attached off the desk onto the hardwood floor. no damage done, so i put it back on the desk, this time further away from the edge. 5 minutes later, another thump, and yet again, i found my camera on the floor with the cat lookin at me wanting to play. I took a picture of him and locked him out of the room.

    walking in the woods, I opened my pack to change a lens. I traded a 16-85G for a 50mm AF-D and left the pack open on my back. I leaned a little to much for a picture and the 16-85 slipped out and hit the dirt hard. still worked, no damage.

    my 105mm G micro is notorious for getting hit. I've never dropped it, but its been knocked over more then enough times to be considered healthy. I've learned to not place it standing up, but rather lay it down or keep it in the pack, but it still some how gets the most abuse in all my kit. good thing its made of metal, but i worry about the VR.

    Posted 2 years ago #
  19. NSXType-R

    preferred member
    Joined: Mar '09
    Posts: 2,803

    offline

    Only some of the 105mm micro is made of metal. Most of the front half is plastic.

    The interior, I assume would be mostly metal.

    Posted 2 years ago #
  20. fstopfitzgerald

    new member
    Joined: May '11
    Posts: 1

    offline

    I was in the interior of Kodiak Iskland, Alaska, USA. The largest meat-eating land animals on earth outnumber people. Where the Fraser River drains Fraser Lake, there's a waterfall where the bears congregate and fish. I'm there with a lot of gear. Two adolescent bears are fishing together, when I decide to hike downstream to the next waterwall, and I don't want to carry my whole kit. I left an F100 with the original 80-200 2.8 AFS lens attached in LowePro bag up by the upper falls and wandered downstream.

    Along comes a BIG bruin. He wants to fish there. In the pecking order of bears, the youngsters leave - fast. They're no up on the small hill where my camera was...

    Shreded the bag, bear saliva and tooth marks all over everything. And 10 years later, I'm still using the lens nearly every day.

    Posted 2 years ago #
  21. Willis

    preferred member
    Joined: Mar '09
    Posts: 1,123

    offline

    Dropped a 24-70 f2.8 which landed face first on the pavement. Amazingly, the optics did just fine, but the zoom ring seized up. $450 to fix.

    Posted 2 years ago #
  22. SSNphoto

    new member
    Joined: May '11
    Posts: 1

    offline

    Many moons ago, I was up in Toronto shooting the Molson Indy and pulled my camera bag out of the back seat of the car. The bag was unzipped and the velcro camera strap wasn't attached. My D2H with 70-200 2.8 attached went flying out of the bag and crashed to the concrete floor of the parking garage. The magnesium casing split into three pieces, one crack around the left controls and one around the hotshoe. I put the pieces back together, taped it heavily with electrical tape, and shot with it for the whole weekend. This happened (of course) on the first morning. I think I had another event a week or two later so I didn't even have a chance to have it properly repaired until after that. I think the only thing that broke on the lens was a UV filter. I don't use it for much any more but I still have the D2H and I just sold that 70-200, still working perfectly.

    Posted 2 years ago #
  23. marty19

    new member
    Joined: Jun '11
    Posts: 1

    offline

    Hello -

    I am intersted in using the 'bridge explosion' picture posted here in a professional presentation. Would whomever owns this photo be able to provide me with written consent for that?

    Thank you,
    Martin

    Posted 1 year ago #
  24. NSXType-R

    preferred member
    Joined: Mar '09
    Posts: 2,803

    offline

    I crapped my pants yesterday when my dad flew a model helicopter into my 105mm macro. I was shooting his helicopter flying indoors- it's really small, smaller than a marble notebook.

    But it only scratched the B and W UV filter I had on it, and I then rubbed it off and washed it with some lens cleaning fluid. It shouldn't be an issue, glass is quite hard and it was only plastic that hit it.

    If it affects my photos, my father is very reasonable with these things, he won't mind getting me another filter.

    Posted 1 year ago #
  25. V.Lad

    new member
    Joined: May '12
    Posts: 4

    offline

    I have recently switched from Canon to Nikon, partially because Nikon seemed more durable. This, of course, wasn't something that I wanted to try out, but today I was standing in a college cafeteria having a cup of coffee when I suddenly felt all of the weight on my right shoulder disappearing followed by a thud on the floor. The strap holding my D7000 and 24-70 2.8 has decided to become loose. Picked it up in shock and walked out. The only damage turned out to be a small barely noticeable scratch on the side of the lens and a dent in the UV filter, no scratches on the body or any impairments to the functionality. It also helped that a staff has brought out my battery slot door 'cause as it turned out it flew off.
    Well, I guess when you invest in good lenses you are not only paying for the glass but also for how long it's going to stay with you.

    Posted 1 year ago #

RSS feed for this topic

« Previous12345Next »

Reply »

You must log in to post.

NikonRumors Forum (http://nikonrumors.com/forum) is proudly powered by bbPress
Disclaimer: This site has no affiliation with Nikon USA or any other subsidiary of Nikon. Please visit the official Nikon website at nikon.com
Copyright © 2008-2011 NikonRumors.com